ManBe Group

Subcontractor liability: when someone else's illegal worker becomes your problem

ManBe Group · 10 November 2026 · 6 min read

Illustration of a site manager and a subcontractor's foreman reviewing a clipboard on a construction site while workers in hi-vis vests work on scaffolding behind them.

If a subcontractor on your site employs a non-EU worker who has no right to stay or work, the problem does not always stop with that subcontractor. EU law lets member states make the contractor above it pay the fines and back wages, and in several countries the main contractor at the top of the chain can be pulled in too. Whether that happens to you depends on two things: the national law where the work is done, and whether you can show you checked.

So the practical answer is simple. Treat every crew that arrives on your site as if its paperwork were your own, write that into your subcontracts, and keep evidence of the checks. The rest of this article explains where the liability comes from, how it differs between countries, and what a sensible check routine looks like for construction, logistics and manufacturing sites.

Where chain liability comes from

The starting point is the Employer Sanctions Directive (2009/52/EC), which sets minimum EU rules against employing third-country nationals who are staying illegally. It requires employers to check a worker's residence permit or other authorisation before hiring, keep a copy for at least the length of the employment, and notify the authorities when the job starts.

When an employer breaks the rules, it faces fines that rise with the number of workers involved, and it must pay the worker's outstanding wages plus the taxes and social security contributions that would have been due. The directive presumes the employment lasted at least three months unless someone proves otherwise, so back pay is rarely trivial.

Article 8 is the part that reaches up the chain:

  • The direct contractor. Where the employer is a subcontractor, the contractor that hired it may be made liable, in addition to or instead of the subcontractor, for the fines and back payments.
  • The main contractor and intermediate subcontractors. They can also be made liable, but only where they knew the employing subcontractor was using illegally staying workers.
  • The due diligence defence. A contractor that has met the due diligence obligations set out in national law is not liable.

The directive also allows exclusion from public contracts and public funding for up to five years, recovery of subsidies received in the previous 12 months and, in serious cases, closure of the premises. For a contractor that lives on public tenders, those measures can matter more than the fine.

How it plays out in different countries

Because this is a directive, each country has written its own version, and the differences are real.

Germany has one of the clearest regimes. Under §98a of the Residence Act (AufenthG), an employer that uses a foreign national without work authorisation must pay the agreed wage, again with a presumed three months of employment. A business that commissioned the work is liable for that payment like a guarantor who cannot insist the worker pursues the employer first. General contractors and intermediate firms are liable too unless they did not know. The way out is due diligence: liability ends if the contractor shows that careful checks gave it good reason to believe no one was being employed without authorisation. The worker can sue in a German labour court.

The Netherlands goes further in practice. Under the Foreign Nationals Employment Act (Wav), the person for whom work is actually done can be treated as the employer, whatever the payroll says. A CMS update from August 2026 describes how several parties in one chain can each be fined separately for the same worker, and how "we did not know how our partner staffed the job" is treated as a weak defence.

Lithuania works differently. The European Labour Authority's 2023 country factsheet lists supply-chain liability as a tool not in use there. Your exposure as a main contractor runs through other routes:

  • Site identification. Everyone doing construction work on a Lithuanian site must hold a Transparent Worker ID code, a QR code generated through Sodra that shows the person's employment or self-employment status and insurer in real time. The developer or its authorised contractor must make sure everyone on site is identified, and may check the codes.
  • Permit consequences for your subcontractor. Since 22 May 2026, a new temporary residence permit is refused to an employer sanctioned for illegal or undeclared work until 12 months have passed from the date the fine decision became final, and existing permits can be revoked on the same grounds. If a subcontractor you rely on is sanctioned, its ability to bring in or keep foreign crews can stop for a year, and your programme stops with it.
  • The employer's own penalties. We cover those in what illegal employment costs a Lithuanian employer.

The common thread is that "it was the subcontractor's worker" is a weaker position than most site managers assume, and the country rules can change.

How informal labour reaches a site

The illegal worker rarely arrives through the contractor you vetted. More often they arrive two or three levels down:

  • A subcontractor short of people for a deadline borrows a crew from another firm on a handshake.
  • A labour supplier sends workers whose permit is tied to a different employer, or whose permit has expired.
  • A worker is presented as self-employed when, in practice, they work under someone's direction.
  • Workers enter on a visa or visa-free stay that does not allow work at all.

Each of these is explained in the five kinds of foreign worker a Lithuanian employer meets. The pattern is the same in construction, warehousing and logistics: the further you are from the person's actual employer, the less you see.

Contract clauses that do real work

A clause will not stop an inspector fining you where national law makes you liable, but it shapes behaviour and gives you a route to recover losses. The clauses worth having:

  1. No further subcontracting without written consent. This keeps the chain short enough to check.
  2. A named worker list before mobilisation. Name, employer, and the basis of each person's right to work, updated before anyone new arrives.
  3. Document delivery. Copies of permits or residence cards and proof of social insurance registration, on request and within a short deadline.
  4. A compliance warranty and indemnity. The subcontractor warrants that everyone it deploys is lawfully employed and indemnifies you for fines, back pay and delay costs.
  5. Audit and removal rights. You may check documents on site at any time and remove anyone who cannot show the right to work, without that counting as your breach.
  6. Termination for cause. A sanction for illegal or undeclared work is grounds to end the contract.

Site checks that hold up

Paperwork in a folder at head office is not due diligence if nobody looks at who is actually on site. A routine that holds up:

  1. Check at the gate, not the office. Compare faces and names against the worker list on the first day of each new person.
  2. Verify, do not just collect. In Lithuania, scan the Transparent Worker ID rather than accepting a photo of it. Elsewhere, check the permit's employer, validity and conditions against the job.
  3. Watch the permit's employer. A permit issued for one employer does not cover work for another.
  4. Repeat without notice. Periodic unannounced checks catch the crew that appears only for the weekend pour.
  5. Keep records. Date, who checked, what was seen, and what was done about anything wrong. Evidence of a routine is what a due diligence defence rests on.

Our right-to-work checklist for Lithuania covers the document side in more detail.

Where ManBe fits

ManBe recruits non-EU workers for construction and other sectors on a direct employment basis only: every worker is hired onto the client's own payroll, under the client's own permit application. That keeps the chain to one link, so you know who employs each person on your site and on what basis.

Rules on chain liability and permits change, and they differ between countries. This article reflects the position as of November 2026 and is not legal advice. If you are planning to hire directly rather than rely on labour from further down the chain, talk to us about your requirement.

#subcontracting#illegal employment#construction#compliance#employer sanctions

FREQUENTLY ASKED

It depends on the country. The EU Employer Sanctions Directive lets member states make the direct contractor liable for fines and back pay, and the main contractor too where it knew about the illegal employment. Germany and the Netherlands both make clients in the chain pay or face fines, while Lithuania relies more on site identification rules and permit consequences.

More from the blog

READY TO BUILD YOUR DREAM TEAM?

Whether you need a single specialist or an entire workforce, ManBe's recruitment experts are here to deliver.

Talk to Recruitment Team